This essay seems to be an attempt to address the issue of saving electricity, but there are several areas that need improvement. Here is the evaluation based on the provided criteria: 
 
1) Content and Task Completion: 
   - The essay attempts to cover the topic by discussing the importance of saving electricity and providing some personal steps the writer plans to take.  
   - However, there are some vague expressions and lack of elaboration on certain points, such as what exactly "reduce using e-book" means in terms of saving electricity. 
   - It does mention the key purpose and some actions which is positive. 
 
2) Language Use: 
   - There are several grammatical and lexical errors: 
     - "increasingly important" should have a noun following it, like "issue". 
     - "sortcoming" should be "scarce" or another word reflecting the shortage. 
     - "I will with my family member to save electricity together" is missing a verb after "will". 
   - Language usage is basic, and there is room for enriching vocabulary and improving sentence structure for clarity and impact. 
 
3) Structure: 
   - The essay follows a basic structure with an introduction, body, and conclusion. 
   - Transition words like "First of all," "What is more," and "Last but not least," suggest an understanding of ordering ideas, though they could be better tied to specific examples or explanations. 
 
4) Clarity and Coherence: 
   - Some parts of the essay are unclear due to grammatical issues, which affect the overall coherence. 
   - More detailed examples and clearer expression of ideas would improve understandability. 
 
In summary, this essay would likely fit into the third or fourth band (7-18 points), as it contains key elements of the task but lacks sufficient clarity, depth, and accuracy in language use to achieve higher scores.  
 
**Suggestions for Improvement:** 
- Clarify the main points and ensure each step mentioned directly relates to saving electricity. 
- Improve grammar and vocabulary to avoid ambiguity, such as explaining how using less of an e-book conserves power. 
- Ensure every sentence has clear meaning and contributes to the overall narrative. 
- Provide more examples or context to explain why each proposed action helps save electricity. 
- Double-check for spelling errors and correct phrases like "sortcoming" and missing verbs. |