After evaluating the composition on Dalian, I would place it in the third tier (13-18 points) of the provided scoring standards. Here are some observations and suggestions for improvement:
1. **Content**: The essay provides a good overview of Dalian as a coastal city with appealing seafood and friendly residents. However, it could be improved by adding more specific examples or details about attractions, culture, or personal experiences in Dalian to enhance reader engagement.
2. **Structure**: The composition is coherent but lacks a clear introduction and conclusion. It would be beneficial to start with a sentence that introduces Dalian's significance or appeal and conclude with a reflection or summary that ties together the main points discussed.
3. **Language Use**:
- **Grammar and Vocabulary**: The vocabulary used is satisfactory, but some expressions can be refined for greater impact. For example, "succulent grilled fish" and "mouthwatering shrimp dishes" are effective, but "friendly city where life's a breeze" could be replaced with more descriptive language.
- **Sentence Variety**: Try to vary sentence structure to improve readability and flow. The sentences currently follow a similar pattern, which can make the text feel repetitive.
- **Tone**: The tone is informal and affectionate, which is suitable for a personal description of one's hometown. However, for a more formal context or assignment, adjusting the tone might be necessary.
4. **Suggestions**:
- Include additional information about cultural aspects or historical significance of Dalian.
- Enhance the description of the climate with more specific examples of how it positively affects activities or lifestyles.
- Address potential areas of development in Dalian if relevant.
Overall, the essay communicates a personal affection for Dalian effectively but could benefit from more comprehensive content and a structured approach to improve clarity and engagement. |